One of my families settled early and stayed long in the county. When I checked the county historical society, the family had a rather large file with copies of obituaries and even photos from early days showing the family members hunting on their farm. These photos would not have been available to me in any other way.
If you are not sure that an historical society is the next best option for your research, consider using the advice feature of this site. This will help you pick your next best steps in your research. Go to Genealogy Search Advice.>